Kalecgos 1 tank SR strat...questions

My point was that it wasn't terrible compared to BoS, and a sidegrade is an appropriate label.

More direct competition in wotlk will be nice, but even as we've seen for DEL it slants toward tanking more than roguing. All the paladin weapons that do so are... daggers...

I'd expect we start seeing a lot of 1.5-speed AGI/expertise/stam swords in WotLK. It's a very reasonable rogue/prot warrior compromise. Then again, with sunder and whatnot scaling to AP, I could see that getting worked into fast 1h's and still being viable for warrior tanking (STR would be better due to vitality, but that basically kills it for rogues).

-Splug
_________________
(Usually) Prot warrior: http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Illidan&n=Splug

To be honest, the gap between the paladin offset tanking gear and warrior offset tanking gear in sunwell isn't that far off.

Threat through expertise
Threat through spellpower

Hypothetically, Felstrength really wouldn't be that bad for paladin tanking, and perhaps even superior for single target work, depending on your spellpower through other factors. Warriors do not see the same case in reverse: lose the expertise in exchange for nothing.

-Splug
_________________
(Usually) Prot warrior: http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Illidan&n=Splug

I always kind of equated str/hit to spellpower. Expertise seems pretty equal in sunwell for both. In that regard, I'm really happy with the sunwell neck/cloak/ring.

In the gear forum we looked at the 'warrior' pants and 14 dodge rating vs some BV was the result I got from it, so they would be superior to me. The rest of the 'warrior' pieces are kind of fail for paladin.

Dude, try being in Bloodlust (US), you have NOTHING to complain about, lol.
_________________
Caelestrasz
Rinforza - 70 Holy Priest
Levie - 21 Ret Paladin

Morokute nigai kajitsu no you ni
Hito no kokoro wo miryou suru no

Kata i'd suggest you to change tone, that kind of tone is for WoW forum, refrain from this kind of childish reaction and don't force me to fix it.
_________________