yes it was a crit.
non crit without any buffs and procs I avg 4600 dmg
crit without buffs/procs it was something like 6600
the above picture is rigged i have most of the important buffs and procs and i am intentionally wearing gear for block value (if you notice i dropped below 490 D).
I was practicing wearing the blue pre-naxx gear but really it has less STR. granted i never did icecrown, all of stormpeaks, or any heroic, so these are "leveling blues". but since they re-itemized T6 to have 0 SD and a bunch of STR instead, I just use it.
I also grind as prot and leveled 79-80 as prot in the blue prot quest reward and low level instance drops. as long as you use seal of wisdom, judge wisdom, blessing of wisdom, dont consecrate, and use our new bloodrage/evocate talent alot, you can do pretty well with grinding and dmg from sor/hotr. Even enough mana to cast AS again and use how.
_________________
http://www.ardentdefender.com - A combat log parsing API