Must choose between 2 trinkets.. need help

I currently use these 2 trinkets:
http://www.wowhead.com/item=56280
http://www.wowhead.com/item=52351 (I know it's a DPS trinket)

I got a new JC quest today and made
http://www.wowhead.com/item=52352

Stats (unbuff)

With stamina figurine:
149.9k HP / 51.50% block

With mastery figurine:
142.7k HP / 55.08% block

Your advices please ?

Edit: http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/S ... ach/simple

You should keep and use all 3 of them, depending on what you are doing. The dodge trinket with a mastery proc would probably have a pretty high uptime on trash, since you spend a bit of downtime between groups drinking/moving/waiting for a cooldown ect. Personally I favor 1 mastery and 1 stam trinket for general use though, and for a time used both of the jc trinkets you listed.

Agreed there - I would use the King of Boars and Earthen Guardian. The crab is still situationally useful, but for most heroics I like a little stam and the option of popping the king of boars for BIG CRITZ \o/